Website Redesign Strategy: What Works, What Fails & How to Get It Right

A website redesign can either bring in more leads and sales—or just leave you with a nicer-looking site that changes nothing. The difference? A clear strategy.

It’s not just about updating the design. It’s about making your website easier to navigate, faster to load, and better at turning visitors into customers. In this guide, we’ll break down what works, what fails, and how to get your redesign right.

‍

Why Most Redesign Efforts Fail

Not every website redesign leads to better results. Some businesses spend months updating their site only to see no change in traffic, leads, or sales. Why? Because they focus on the wrong things.

Here’s what often goes wrong:

1. Prioritizing Looks Over Functionality

A sleek design is great, but if your site is harder to navigate or doesn’t guide visitors toward the right actions, it’s a problem. A redesign should improve user experience (UX), speed, and conversions—not just aesthetics.

2. No Clear Goals

Many redesigns start with vague objectives like “modernizing the site” or “making it look fresh.” Without clear, measurable goals—like increasing form submissions or reducing bounce rates—you won’t know if the redesign is actually working.

3. Ignoring User Behavior

If you’re not looking at real data before making changes, you’re guessing. Heatmaps, session recordings, and analytics can tell you what’s working and what’s frustrating visitors. Skipping this step leads to decisions based on opinions, not facts.

4. Overcomplicating the Site

Adding too many animations, sections, or unnecessary features can slow down the site and overwhelm users. A good redesign simplifies the experience, making it easier for visitors to find what they need and take action.

5. Neglecting SEO & Redirects

A common mistake is removing or restructuring pages without setting up proper 301 redirects. This can cause a major drop in search rankings and organic traffic, undoing years of SEO work.

6. Thinking the Job Is Done After Launch

A redesign isn’t a one-and-done project. If you don’t track how the new site is performing and make adjustments based on user feedback, you could miss out on easy improvements that drive more conversions.

A website redesign should do more than look good—it should work better, convert better, and drive results. Next, we’ll break down how to set yourself up for success and avoid these mistakes.

‍

Setting Yourself Up for Success

A successful website redesign doesn’t happen by accident. The businesses that see real results like more leads, higher conversions, better user engagement—approach the process with a clear strategy rather than just updating the design.

Here’s how to set the right foundation before making any changes:

1. Define Clear, Measurable Goals

Redesigning a website just to “modernize it” isn’t a strategy. You need specific targets that will tell you if the new site is actually working.

Bad goal: "Make the site look fresh"

Good goal: "Increase demo bookings by 20% within 3 months"

Other examples of clear goals:

• Reduce bounce rate from 60% to 45%
• Increase form submissions by 30%
• Improve page load speed to under 2 seconds
• Boost organic traffic by 15%

The more specific the goal, the easier it is to measure success.

2. Use Data to Guide Decisions

Before making changes, analyze how your current site is performing.

• Check Google Analytics – Where are visitors dropping off? Which pages drive the most conversions?
• Use heatmaps (Microsoft Clarity, Hotjar) – Are users scrolling, clicking, or getting stuck somewhere?
• Gather customer feedback – Ask real users what confuses them or stops them from taking action.

These insights will tell you what’s working—and what needs fixing—so you redesign with purpose, not guesswork.

3. Align the Redesign With Your Business & Brand

Your website should reflect who you are today and support where you're going next. If your company has evolved, your site should too.

Ask yourself:

• Does the messaging clearly explain what we do and who we help?
• Is the design aligned with our brand’s personality and positioning?
• Are we addressing our ideal customers’ biggest pain points?

A strong redesign isn’t just a visual upgrade—it should help potential customers understand your value and take action faster.

Next, we’ll go deeper into the pre-redesign audit—where we assess content, UX, and technical foundations to make sure nothing is overlooked.

‍

Pre-Redesign Audit: Content, UX & Tech Check

Before making any changes, you need to understand what’s working and what’s not on your current website. A redesign without an audit is like rebuilding a house without inspecting the foundation—you might be fixing the wrong problems.

A proper audit helps you keep the elements that drive results, improve the areas that need work, and remove what’s no longer useful. Here’s what to assess before moving forward.

1. Content: What to Keep, Improve, or Remove

Your website’s design can only do so much—the content is what actually sells. If visitors don’t understand what you offer, why it matters, or what to do next, no amount of design improvements will fix that.

How to Audit Your Content:

• Check your messaging – Is it clear, concise, and focused on the visitor’s needs?
• Review performance data – Which pages drive the most leads or conversions? Which pages have high bounce rates?
• Identify gaps – Are there missing resources, FAQs, or case studies that would help visitors make a decision?
• Evaluate consistency – Does your content reflect your current brand voice and positioning?

Decide what to do next:

• Keep: High-performing pages with strong messaging.
• Improve: Outdated content, weak CTAs, or unclear messaging.
• Remove: Pages with little traffic or relevance.

2. UX (User Experience): Is Your Site Helping or Hurting Conversions?

A visually appealing website is meaningless if visitors can’t find what they need or take action easily. Your UX audit should focus on how people navigate your site and whether it’s helping or frustrating them.

Key Areas to Assess:

• Navigation: Is the menu structured logically? Can visitors find key pages easily?
• Mobile Usability: Does the site work smoothly on all devices? A frustrating mobile experience will drive visitors away.
• Conversion Paths: How easy is it for visitors to complete important actions (like filling out a form, booking a demo, or contacting sales)?
• Loading Speed: A slow site can hurt both user experience and SEO. Google recommends page load times under 2.5 seconds.

How to Get Real UX Insights:

• Use Google Analytics to see where visitors drop off.
• Run heatmaps (Microsoft Clarity, Hotjar) to track user behavior.
• Conduct user testing to watch how real people interact with your site.

3. Tech Check: Performance, SEO, & Security

Even a great-looking website will fail if it’s slow, unsecure, or difficult to find on search engines. Your tech audit ensures that your redesign doesn’t just look good—it works well, too.

Key Areas to Review:

• Site Speed: Check with tools like Google PageSpeed Insights and Webflow Analyze. Slow load times drive visitors away.
• SEO Structure: Are your title tags, meta descriptions, and heading structures optimized? Are there any broken links or missing redirects?
• Security: Ensure your SSL certificate is active and your website is protected from vulnerabilities.
• Integrations & Functionality: Does everything connect properly (CRM, forms, chat tools)? If not, now’s the time to fix it.

Now that you have a better insight of where you stand in terms of your current website, we’ll cover how to turn these insights into a clear redesign strategy so that every update you make drives better results.

And if you need a checklist to follow along with your redesign process, check out Amply’s Website Redesign Checklist.

‍

Crafting a Website Strategy That Works

Now that you’ve audited your current website, it’s time to create a clear strategy for your redesign. Without a plan, you risk making changes that look good but don’t actually improve performance. A strong website strategy ensures that every update, whether it’s design, content, or functionality, moves the needle on leads, conversions, and user experience.

Here’s how to do it right:

1. Prioritize High-Impact Pages First

Not every page needs a complete overhaul. Focus on the pages that drive the most business value first.

Key pages to prioritize:

• Homepage: Sets the first impression and guides visitors to key actions.
• Services/Product Pages: Should clearly communicate value and drive inquiries or sales.
• Pricing Page: Should remove friction and help visitors make informed decisions.
• Lead Capture Pages: Contact forms, demo requests, and signup pages should be optimized for conversions.

If a page isn’t helping users take the next step, it needs attention.

2. Design for Clarity, Not Just Looks

A website redesign should make things easier for visitors, not just more visually appealing.

What works:

✔ Simple, clear navigation that helps visitors find what they need.

✔ Easy-to-read fonts and layouts that guide attention.

✔ High-contrast CTAs (calls to action) that stand out and encourage action.

✔ White space and clean design that make information digestible.

What fails:

✖ Overly complex layouts that overwhelm visitors.

✖ Too many animations or distractions that slow things down.

✖ Generic stock images that don’t connect with your audience.

You can find more references and ideas for your website redesign on our SaaS website redesigns page.

3. Make Content More Actionable

Your content should answer visitor questions quickly and guide them toward the next step.

How to improve content during a redesign:

• Simplify your messaging – Avoid jargon and make it clear what you offer.
• Use scannable sections – Break content into short paragraphs, subheadings, and bullet points.
• Refine your CTAs – Every page should have a clear action (book a call, get a quote, sign up).

A redesign is the perfect time to update outdated content, fix weak messaging, and make every page work harder for your business.

4. Ensure Mobile & Performance Optimization

A redesign shouldn’t just look good on desktop—it needs to be fast and functional on all devices.

Key areas to focus on:

• Mobile responsiveness: The site should adjust seamlessly on any screen size.
• Page speed: Compress images, minimize code, and avoid heavy elements that slow down load times.
• Accessibility: Ensure text is readable, buttons are easy to tap, and color contrast meets accessibility standards.

A slow or clunky mobile site will lose visitors fast—this is a non-negotiable part of your strategy.

‍

Mistakes That Can Undermine Your Redesign (And How to Avoid Them)

Even with a solid strategy, some redesigns still fail to deliver results. Why? Because they fall into avoidable mistakes that slow down the site, hurt conversions, or undo years of SEO efforts.

Here are the biggest redesign mistakes—and how to make sure your site stays on track.

1. Prioritizing Aesthetics Over Functionality

A fresh design is great, but if it makes your site harder to use, it’s a step backward.

The mistake:

• Overly complex layouts that confuse visitors.
• Too many animations that slow the site down.
• A “minimal” design that removes helpful information.

How to get it right:

• Keep navigation simple and intuitive.
• Design for clarity first—then refine the visuals.
• Test usability with real users before launching.

A website should look good, but its real job is to help visitors take action.

2. Neglecting SEO & Search Rankings

A redesign can accidentally wipe out years of SEO work if not handled carefully.

The mistake:

• Deleting or renaming important pages without setting up proper redirects.
• Forgetting to optimize title tags, meta descriptions, and internal linking.
• Launching a new design with broken URLs or missing structured data.

How to get it right:

• Use 301 redirects for any pages that are being removed or updated.
• Keep your high-ranking pages intact and optimize them further.
• Run a full SEO audit post-launch to catch any indexing issues.

3. Slowing Down the Site with Heavy Design Choices

Visitors leave when a site takes too long to load. Google also ranks slow sites lower in search results.

The mistake:

• Large, uncompressed images and videos.
• Too many custom fonts or bloated code.
• Overuse of interactive elements that add unnecessary load time.

How to get it right:

• Optimize images before uploading.
• Use lightweight code and fonts to speed up loading times.
• Stick to only necessary animations—if they don’t improve UX, remove them.

A fast site keeps visitors engaged and improves SEO—speed is not optional.

4. Ignoring Mobile Experience

More than half of all web traffic is mobile. A great desktop design means nothing if the mobile version is frustrating to use.

The mistake:

• Buttons that are too small or hard to tap.
• Text that’s difficult to read on smaller screens.
• Layouts that break or require too much scrolling.

How to get it right:

• Test your redesign on multiple devices before launch.
• Ensure all buttons and text are mobile-friendly.
• Keep forms, menus, and checkout flows simple and seamless.

A bad mobile experience can drive potential customers away before they even get started.

5. Launching Without Testing & Tracking

A redesign isn’t finished when the new site goes live—it’s just the beginning.

The mistake:

• Launching without checking for broken links, missing pages, or tracking issues.
• Assuming the redesign is perfect instead of tracking performance.
• Ignoring user feedback post-launch.

How to get it right:

• Run a full site QA before launch to check speed, links, and forms.
• Set up Google Analytics, Webflow Analyze, and heatmaps to track user behavior.
• Gather real user feedback to fine-tune your site based on visitor experience.

A great website evolves over time—ongoing tracking and improvements are key.

Now that you know what to avoid, let’s talk about the technical foundations and SEO strategy that will make sure your new site is not just visually appealing—but also fast, search-friendly, and built for long-term success.

‍

Technical Foundations & SEO Strategy

Without a solid technical foundation, even the best-designed site can struggle with slow load times, poor rankings, and a frustrating user experience.

Here’s what you need to focus on to ensure your redesigned site is optimized from day one.

1. Site Speed & Performance Optimization

A slow website drives visitors away and hurts your search rankings. Google prioritizes fast-loading websites, and so do your users.

Key areas to improve:

• Image Optimization: Use next-gen formats like WebP and compress large images before uploading.
• Efficient Code Structure: Webflow generates clean, lightweight code that reduces bloat compared to traditional page builders.
• Minimize Unnecessary Scripts: Too many third-party scripts (like chat widgets or heavy analytics) can slow down performance.

How to check your speed:

• Use Google PageSpeed Insights to analyze performance.
• Check Webflow’s built-in performance tools for real-time insights.

A fast website means better user experience, lower bounce rates, and higher rankings.

2. Mobile-First Optimization

More than half of web traffic comes from mobile. If your site isn’t optimized for smaller screens, you’re losing potential customers.

What to check:

• Responsive Design: Ensure layouts adapt seamlessly to different screen sizes.
• Tap-Friendly Elements: Buttons and links should be easy to click, with enough spacing around them.
• Simplified Navigation: Avoid complex menus—make it easy for mobile users to find key pages.

Webflow makes mobile optimization effortless, allowing you to build and preview designs specifically for different devices.

3. SEO Migration & Redirects

One of the biggest mistakes businesses make during a redesign is not handling SEO properly. If you delete or restructure pages without setting up 301 redirects, you risk losing valuable search traffic.

How to protect your SEO:

• Set Up 301 Redirects: If URLs are changing, redirect old links to relevant new pages.
• Retain High-Performing Pages: Keep pages that are already ranking well and refine them further.
• Optimize Title Tags & Meta Descriptions: Ensure every page has a compelling title and description to improve click-through rates.
• Update Your Sitemap: Once the new site is live, submit the updated sitemap to Google Search Console to ensure fast indexing.

Webflow allows you to set up redirects easily, ensuring a seamless transition without losing SEO momentum.

4. Structured Data & Schema Markup

Schema markup helps search engines understand your content better and can improve how your site appears in results (like showing star ratings, FAQs, or event details directly on Google).

What to add:

• Breadcrumb Schema – Helps users navigate your site efficiently.
• FAQ Schema – Makes FAQs more likely to show up in search results.
• Organization Schema – Strengthens brand identity in Google’s knowledge panel.

Using Google’s Structured Data Testing Tool, you can verify that your schema is correctly implemented.

5. Security & Compliance

Security isn’t just about preventing hacks—it also impacts SEO and user trust. A secure site ranks better and ensures visitors feel safe sharing their information.

Must-have security measures:

• SSL Certificate – Essential for data encryption and required for ranking well on Google.
• Regular Security Audits – Use tools like Google Safe Browsing to check for vulnerabilities.
• GDPR & Privacy Compliance – If you collect user data, make sure your privacy policies are up to date.

Webflow includes SSL by default, ensuring your site meets modern security standards from launch.

‍

Tools & Tech Stack to Get Your Website Revamp Right

A well-executed redesign isn’t just about strategy—it’s about using the right tools to bring that strategy to life. From design and development to lead capture and performance tracking, your tech stack plays a major role in how effective your new website will be.

Here’s what we recommend:

1. Webflow: The Best Platform for B2B Websites

Many businesses redesign their site only to realize they’re still stuck with rigid templates, slow performance, or the need for ongoing developer support. That’s why we recommend Webflow.

Why Webflow?

• Complete design control – No restrictive templates. Build exactly what you need.
• Fast & lightweight – Webflow’s clean code and built-in performance optimizations help pages load faster.
• SEO-ready from the start – Custom meta titles, structured data, and fast loading speeds give you an edge in search rankings.
• No-code updates – Easily change content, layouts, and pages without needing a developer every time.

Unlike traditional platforms, Webflow lets you focus on creating a high-performing site without the technical headaches. That’s why we use it for our own sites and our clients’ projects.

2. Lead Capture & CRM Integration

Your website isn’t just a brochure—it’s a lead generation tool. But if your forms, pop-ups, or landing pages aren’t connected to the right tools, you’ll lose potential customers before they even get a response.

Recommended Tools:

• HubSpot – Great for capturing leads, managing email follow-ups, and automating outreach.
• Webflow Forms + Zapier – Automatically send form submissions to your CRM, email, or Slack.
• Calendly – Embed scheduling tools directly into your site to streamline demo and consultation bookings.

3. Performance & Analytics Tracking

Redesigning your website isn’t enough—you need to track how it performs and continuously improve it.

Recommended Tools:

• Webflow Analyze – Webflow’s built-in analytics let you track key metrics without needing extra plugins.
• Google Analytics – Get deeper insights into user behavior, traffic sources, and conversion rates.
• Microsoft Clarity – Use heatmaps and session recordings to see how visitors interact with your site.

4. SEO & Visibility Optimization

Your redesign should improve search rankings, not hurt them. That’s why it’s critical to have the right SEO tools in place.

Recommended Tools:

• Google Search Console – Monitor indexing, fix errors, and track how Google sees your site.
• SEMrush – Conduct keyword research and track SEO improvements post-redesign.
• Webflow’s Built-In SEO Tools – Easily manage meta tags, sitemaps, and structured data directly in Webflow.

5. A/B Testing & Conversion Optimization

Once your redesigned site is live, you should continuously test and optimize to improve conversions.

Recommended Tools:

• Webflow Optimize – Run A/B tests and personalize content directly in Webflow.
• Optibase – Test different versions of landing pages, CTAs, and headlines to see what drives more conversions.

‍

Launch & Post-Launch Optimization

A website redesign isn’t finished the moment it goes live. The real work begins after launch—tracking performance, fixing issues, and optimizing for better results. Without a proper launch plan, you risk running into broken links, SEO drops, or missed conversion opportunities.

Here’s how to make sure your site launch is smooth and sets you up for long-term success.

1. Soft Launch vs. Full Launch: Choosing the Right Approach

Before pushing everything live, consider whether a soft launch or full launch is the right move.

• Soft Launch (Recommended for Larger Websites)
  
  • Release the new site to a limited audience (internal teams, beta users, or specific regions).
  • Monitor for bugs, usability issues, and SEO changes before rolling out to everyone.
  • Ideal for e-commerce sites, SaaS platforms, or high-traffic websites.
• Full Launch (For Simpler Websites)
  
  • If your site has minimal functionality (e.g., a marketing site with static pages), a full launch may be fine.
  • Just ensure everything has been tested thoroughly before switching over.

A soft launch helps catch issues early, preventing a bad experience for all visitors at once.

2. Final Pre-Launch Checklist

Before flipping the switch, run a final quality assurance (QA) check to ensure everything is working as expected.

Technical & SEO Checks:

• Run a full site speed test using Google PageSpeed Insights.
• Ensure all redirects (301s) are in place for changed or removed URLs.
• Submit an updated sitemap to Google Search Console.
• Double-check meta titles, descriptions, and heading structures for every page.

Content & UX Checks:

• Test navigation and links to ensure nothing is broken.
• Review forms and lead capture flows—are submissions going to the right place?
• Test on multiple devices and browsers to ensure everything looks and functions correctly.

Security & Compliance Checks:

• Confirm SSL is active for secure browsing.
• Review GDPR/privacy policy compliance if you collect visitor data.

A thorough pre-launch check prevents last-minute surprises and ensures a smooth transition.

3. Monitoring Performance Post-Launch

Once the site is live, don’t assume everything is perfect—watch the data closely in the first few weeks.

Key metrics to track:

• Traffic & Rankings: Monitor Google Search Console and SEMrush to see if rankings drop or pages get deindexed.
• Bounce Rate & Engagement: Use Google Analytics to check if users are leaving quickly or struggling to navigate.
• Form Submissions & Conversions: Ensure leads, demo requests, or purchases are coming through as expected.
• User Behavior Insights: Use Microsoft Clarity or Hotjar heatmaps to see how users interact with the new layout.

If any major issues arise—such as a dip in traffic or conversion rates—act fast to troubleshoot and fix them.

4. Ongoing Testing & Optimization

A great website is never “finished.” The best-performing sites are continuously refined based on real data.

How to optimize after launch:

• Run A/B tests (with Webflow Optimize or Optibase) to see what CTAs, headlines, or layouts drive more conversions.
• Keep an eye on site speed and performance, optimizing where necessary.
• Gather user feedback through surveys or customer interviews to spot areas for improvement.
• Regularly update content and SEO to keep the site fresh and relevant.

Treat your website like a living asset that evolves over time, not a one-time project.

‍

Conclusion & Next Steps

A website redesign your opportunity to improve performance, boost conversions, and make your site a true growth driver for your business. Make sure you have a clear strategy, the right tools, and ongoing optimization processes to ensure your site works better, not just looks better.

Key Takeaways from This Guide:

1. Set Clear Goals – Define measurable outcomes before making any changes.
2. Audit Before Redesigning – Identify what’s working, what’s not, and where to focus.
3. Focus on User Experience – Prioritize clear navigation, mobile-friendliness, and fast load times.
4. Protect Your SEO – Implement redirects, optimize content, and track performance post-launch.
5. Use the Right Tech Stack – Platforms like Webflow give you flexibility, speed, and control.
6. Test & Optimize Continuously – A redesign is just the beginning—track results and improve over time.

Ready to Get Your Redesign Right?

If you want expert guidance on planning, designing, and launching a high-performing B2B website, we can help. Book a call to discuss your redesign goals and get a strategy tailored to your business.

Your website is one of your most valuable assets—let’s make sure it’s working as hard as it should.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How do I know if my site really needs a redesign?

If your website isn’t bringing in leads, feels outdated, is slow to load, or is difficult to navigate, it’s likely time for a redesign. A good indicator is if your competitors’ sites are easier to use or rank higher in search results.

2. Will a redesign hurt my SEO rankings?

Not if done correctly. The biggest risks to SEO come from deleting pages without redirects, changing URLs without updating internal links, or ignoring meta data. By implementing 301 redirects, keeping high-performing content intact, and optimizing new pages, your redesign can actually improve search rankings over time.

3. How long does a website redesign take?

It depends on the complexity of your site. A small to mid-sized website can take 6–12 weeks, while larger, more complex sites may take several months. The key is to balance speed with thorough testing and optimization.

4. Do I have to redesign everything at once?

Not necessarily. If a full redesign isn’t feasible right away, you can prioritize high-impact pages (homepage, pricing, lead-gen pages) first and roll out updates in phases. This approach reduces risk and allows for iterative improvements.

5. What’s the best platform for a B2B website redesign?

We recommend Webflow because it offers design flexibility, built-in SEO tools, and a no-code editor, allowing you to make updates without needing a developer. Unlike template-based platforms, Webflow gives you complete control over your site’s look and performance.

6. What should I focus on after launching my new site?

Post-launch, track key metrics like traffic, bounce rates, conversions, and user behavior to see how your changes are performing. Use heatmaps and session recordings to spot usability issues, and run A/B tests to refine messaging and CTAs. A website isn’t a one-time project—it should be continuously optimized for better results.

7. How can I make sure my new site converts better than the old one?

• Simplify navigation so visitors can find what they need quickly.
• Use clear and compelling calls to action (CTAs) on key pages.
• Optimize for speed and mobile responsiveness.
• Test different versions of pages using A/B testing tools like Webflow Optimize or Optibase.

8. Can I redesign my website without losing existing leads and traffic?

Yes, but you need a structured approach. Before launching the new site, ensure that all lead capture forms are properly integrated, existing traffic sources are maintained, and SEO migration steps (redirects, metadata updates) are completed.